EDUCATION MATTERS: Virtue Ethics for the Catholic Leader (Part Three)

By Dr Gerard Gaskin, Executive Director of Catholic Education Tasmania

In Part Three we will further explore Virtue Ethics and moral character, as well as its historical background and some practical implications.

Historical Background

Virtue ethics has its roots in ancient Greek philosophy, particularly in the works of Plato and Aristotle. Aristotle’s Nicomachean Ethics is one of the most influential texts in this tradition. Contemporary philosophers like Alasdair MacIntyre and Martha Nussbaum have further developed virtue ethics, emphasising its relevance in modern moral philosophy.

Moral Character: Virtue ethics focuses on the development of a person’s character. It is built on the idea that by cultivating good habits and virtues, individuals can become morally good people. We are good at the things we practise the most. It’s a simple idea but it reveals a profound truth.

It is an explicit goal of Catholic education that we seek to form morally good people. This means that we encourage our students to make good choices, ones that benefit themselves and others. Equally we want our leaders to set high standards of moral behaviour. We expect our leaders to exhibit good character. Put simply, moral behaviour comes from seeking to do the right thing in every situation.

A part of the Catholic Education Tasmania Virtues Leadership Program that we provide for our employees is built on this basic understanding. By judging all three aspects of any act: (i) the act, (ii) the circumstances and (iii) the intention, we have a practical decision-making framework. Our aspiring leaders learn that all three aspects of the decision need to be morally good for it to be a morally good decision. The leadership program provides our participants with these helpful ethical frameworks that support our aspiring leaders as they practice the skills of good decision making.

Good leadership certainly requires moral character. The good news is that the more we practice making better decisions the better leaders we will become. Like all desirable things, effective leadership requires practice.

Consequentialism: is a very popular, but harmful ethical theory. It focuses only on the outcomes of actions. In doing so it does not consider whether an act (act, intention, circumstances) itself is morally good or otherwise. Virtue ethics, in contrast, emphasises the importance of developing a good character. Essentially, consequentialism judges the morality of an action based on its consequences. It asserts that the best action is the one that produces the most favourable outcome, often defined as maximising good or minimising harm. Essentially, for consequentialism, the ends justify the means. It asserts that we can do bad things in order to achieve a good outcome. As such, it contradicts Catholic moral ethics and strips human actions of any virtuous value – when the only thing that matters is the outcome – no matter how it is achieved.

Gradualism suggests that moral status: the degree to which something is good or bad; is not an absolute concept but rather a matter of degree that develops over time. This perspective is often applied to the moral status of the unborn person, where the child’s moral status is seen as increasing as it develops in the womb. This kind of thinking denies the underlying principle that taking innocent life, whether unborn, and no matter how undeveloped it may be, is always evil. This is a highly dangerous theory because it relies on a set of changing circumstances to determine right or wrong, rather than to focus on certain acts which are always intrinsically evil.

Tags: Education Matters